By
Lisabet Sarai
Opposites
attract.
We’ve
all heard the saying, dozens of times. But is it true?
In
real life, I have my doubts. However, the trope has abiding
popularity, especially in the romance genre. The impoverished but
virtuous serving wench wins the heart of the wealthy, titled rake.
The mousy office temp catches the eye of the billionaire CEO. The
virgin librarian finds herself swept up in the hedonistic world of
the rock idol. The sophisticated city gal moves out west, only to end
up with the gruff, unpolished (but rugged and handsome) cowboy.
Hey,
I plead guilty to using the device myself. In Challenge
to Him, set in the first decade of the twenty century, my
heroine Olivia is a liberated, intellectual labor activist. Somehow
she finds love with a robber baron whose riches depend on the
oppressed masses. Theo, in The
Gazillionaire and the Virgin, is a surly,
sexually-inexperienced recluse who grew up on the wrong side of the
tracks. Yet he manages to snag the affection of extroverted,
media-savvy Silicon Valley hotshot Rachel, who’s had dozens of
lovers.
The
attraction of opposites shows up in a lot of erotica,
too. In these stories, “opposite” often means unfamiliar,
forbidden, even dangerous. A buttoned up career woman ends up with
her back against the brick wall of an alley, being fucked without
mercy by a luridly tatooed biker. A hen-pecked husband takes a risk
and hires a glamorous, seductive high class hooker for a night. A
petite, Caucasian woman gives in to her craving for a huge, well-hung
Black man. In my erotic story “Muse”,
a popular author of erotic romance discovers she’s being stalked by
the scruffy janitor of her apartment building – and that he’s
exactly the sort of stern and demanding Master she has secretly
craved all her life.
Why
does the “opposites attract” trope work so well in erotic
fiction? To be honest, I think we’re trading on everyone’s
contrary fantasies. The sexual grass is always greener over on the
neighbor’s lawn. We imagine how exciting love and lust could be, if
it were somehow different from what we actually experience.
Nothing seems hotter than sex with a stranger —
a real stranger, someone from a totally different world, with
a different background, different expectations, different tastes.
(Perhaps this explains the popularity of alien abduction!)
For
the romantically-inclined, there’s another angle to consider. In
the most satisfying romance, love conquers all. It bridges gaps,
heals divisions, harmonizes even the most extreme differences. The
greater the disparity between the protagonists, the more impressive
and affecting we find love’s ultimate triumph.
Fiction
is designed to entertain, to enlighten, to provide cathartic
identification with the characters. It’s exciting, fascinating and
novel to fantasize about loving (or fucking) the Other.
In
the real world, though —
well, at least in my personal experience —
I’m not likely to be attracted to someone who is truly opposite to
me. I’m never going to be drawn to a rap musician who sings about
beating up his bitches. I can’t imagine connecting with a rabid
sports fan, or someone who spends six hours a day in the gym, or, to
be honest, with a millionaire. I just couldn’t communicate with
people whose priorities were so different from mine —
and great sex, even for one night, depends on communication as much
as on chemistry.
All
of my serious relationships and most of my casual encounters have
involved people with whom I had quite a lot in common: educational
level, intellect, values, and interests. Most of my lovers have cared
more about books than money, more about world peace than basketball,
more about new experiences than new things.
I
do believe in biologically-based attraction. There have been a few
times in my life when I’ve been inexplicably drawn to someone who
seemed all wrong, a panoply of opposites. Usually it turned out that
he or she was wrong for me,
the chemistry spoiled by a persistent lack of comfort.
Hence,
I tend to be skeptical when people claim that opposites attract.
Except, of course, in books.



